Your Cart is Empty
Get 10% off all orders over £50. Discount applied automatically at checkout.
Get 10% off all orders over £50. Discount applied automatically at checkout.
Both bags do the same basic job. They hold your phone where you can glance at it, carry small essentials, and keep everything dry in UK rain. The question is where you mount them. A top tube bag sits on the crossbar between the stem and saddle. A handlebar bag clamps to the bars in front of you. That single decision changes how the bag handles, how much it fits, and how easy it is to use mid-ride.
If you're picking between the BTR top tube bag and the BTR handlebar bag with sun visor, this is the call you're making. Here's how each one fares once you actually ride with it.
The two bags use the same basic ingredients. Both have a waterproof shell, a clear top window for your phone, and storage underneath for keys, cards, gels and a multi-tool. What changes is the mount point.
A top tube bag sits flat on the crossbar, held by velcro straps that loop around the top tube and behind the stem. The phone window faces straight up. To see your screen you look down between your knees.
A handlebar bag clamps to the bars themselves, sitting forward of the stem. The phone window faces back toward you at roughly the angle of your gaze when you ride upright. BTR's version adds a fabric sun visor above the window, which shades the screen on bright days.
That mount-point difference drives almost everything else, from capacity to aerodynamics to how the bag interacts with your knees on a climb.
The bag sits in line with the frame, taking up almost no extra cross-section. Triathletes and road riders pick top tube bags partly because they barely affect drag at speed. The penalty against a handlebar bag is small but real on longer rides.
Anything in the bag sits near the centre of the bike's mass. You don't feel it through the bars, which means steering stays light and predictable.
If you run a bike computer, a bell, or extra lights on your handlebars, you've already used up the bar real estate. A top tube bag adds storage without crowding any of that.
Three straps hold the bag down: two around the top tube, one looped behind the stem. It doesn't sway when you're out of the saddle climbing or sprinting for a green light.
Once it's on, it stays on. Most riders just leave the bag attached and treat it like part of the bike. No daily setup, no fiddling.
Handlebar bags hold more, full stop. BTR's handlebar bag with sun visor takes a packable rain jacket, gloves, a wallet, a phone and tools with room to spare. The top tube version handles a phone, keys and a couple of energy gels.
The screen sits at the same height as your handlebars. When you glance at directions, you're looking straight ahead, not down between your knees. That's safer in traffic and easier on your neck over a long ride.
Phone screens are hard to read under direct sunlight. BTR's handlebar bag has a fabric visor above the window that shades the screen. This single feature is missing from almost every other phone bag on the market and it makes a real difference on bright winter mornings or low summer evenings.
UK roads in winter mean grit, mud and standing water. A handlebar bag sits clear of the spray zone. A top tube bag on the crossbar catches more of it, especially if you don't run mudguards.
Reaching forward and flicking open a handlebar bag takes less time than fumbling between your thighs. Useful for snacks, lip balm or a tissue without stopping.
Sloping top tubes, compact frames, folders and small women's bikes often don't have enough top tube length for a top tube bag to sit cleanly. A handlebar bag clamps to the bars regardless of frame geometry.
Both bags are waterproof and both have a phone window. The choice isn't about quality, it's about how you ride.
Handlebar bag. You want the phone at eye line, the sun visor for low winter sun, and the capacity for a packable waterproof.
Top tube bag. You're not navigating, you don't need much capacity, and the aero shape is a small but real bonus over distance.
Top tube bag, often paired with a separate handlebar harness for bigger loads. The low weight stays out of the way on rough terrain.
Handlebar bag. The top tube on most folders is too short to mount anything useful.
Handlebar bag. Most modern frames have less top tube real estate than they used to, and a top tube bag can rub your knees on every pedal stroke.
Handlebar bag. Knee rub is the single most common complaint about top tube bags in real cyclist reviews. Smaller frames make it worse.
Top tube bag. You've already filled the bars.
Either bag works. Pick on price, aesthetic preference or whether the sun visor matters to you.
Yes, and plenty of cyclists do. Bikepackers routinely run a top tube bag for snacks and tools plus a handlebar bag or roll for clothes and a sleeping mat. UK commuters sometimes pair the two: top tube bag for keys, wallet and phone; handlebar bag for the packable waterproof, a banana and a buff.
The two BTR bags don't conflict with each other physically. The top tube bag sits behind the stem; the handlebar bag sits in front of it. If you carry a lot, or if you ride year round through changing conditions, running both bags roughly doubles your usable storage without compromising either.
A few practical things to confirm regardless of which bag you pick.
Modern phones are bigger than they were five years ago. Pro Max and Ultra models can be too long for older top tube bags. BTR's bags are sized for current phones, but if you ride with a Samsung Galaxy S25 Ultra or iPhone 17 Pro Max in a thick case, measure before you order. Our phone fit guide covers the BTR bags in detail.
Stand over your bike and measure your top tube. If you have less than about 50cm of usable length between the stem and the saddle, a top tube bag will probably rub. Sloping top tubes lose even more usable space.
Bulky cases with cardholders or thick wallets can push the phone above the window line. Check the bag's stated phone depth against your case.
The window has to be responsive enough for the touchscreen to register through it. BTR's TPU windows work with all standard phone screens, including face unlock and fingerprint sensors on the side of the device.
Both BTR bags use sealed seams and waterproof zips. If you're shopping elsewhere, check whether "water resistant" is the same as "waterproof". They aren't always. For a deeper read on this, see our pillar best bike phone holder UK 2026 guide.
If you're a UK commuter, especially in a hilly or rainy area, the handlebar bag with sun visor is the more versatile pick. The capacity, the eye-line phone position and the sun visor each solve a real daily problem.
If you ride mostly on familiar roads, value the aero shape, or already have a busy cockpit, the top tube bag with phone holder keeps things low, central and out of the way. Our bike top tube bag buyer's guide goes deeper on that side of the choice.
Both bags are waterproof, both hold the phone where you can glance at it, and both sit under £20. If you'd like to see the full BTR bike bag range side by side, browse the bike bags collection.
Still weighing up a bag against a simple handlebar mount? Our how to carry your phone safely while cycling guide covers every option, including the trade-offs around weather, security and screen visibility.
It depends on your frame size and pedalling style. Riders on smaller or sloping-top-tube frames are most affected. If you ride out of the saddle a lot, or if you have wider hips, a handlebar bag is the safer choice.
Yes. The bag clamps to standard handlebar diameters and works on flat bars, drop bars and bullhorn bars. The mount sits on the centre of the bar in front of the stem and doesn't interfere with shifters or brake hoods.
On bright UK mornings, yes. Phone screens in direct sun become unreadable, and a fabric visor cuts most of the glare hitting the window. If you commute east to west in the morning or use phone-based navigation on sunny days, it's a meaningful feature that's hard to find on competing bags.
Both bags are waterproof, with sealed seams and waterproof zips. Your phone stays dry in heavy UK rain. Worth noting: the BTR silicone phone mount is not waterproof, so if rain is the deciding factor in your kit choice, a bag beats a mount every time.
Yes, and lots of riders do. The top tube bag sits behind the stem, the handlebar bag sits in front. They don't interfere with each other, and together they roughly double your usable storage compared to a single bag.
Both BTR bags accommodate current Pro Max and Ultra-sized phones in reasonable cases. If you run a thick wallet case or a bulky rugged case, check the spec on the product page before ordering, or contact us with your phone model and case and we'll tell you whether it fits.
Save 10% on your first BTR order
BTR product and company updates and special offers. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
